1. At what point did you decide to take action and act for the investors?
Reply: I was shocked to read in the papers about the failure of the Minibonds, High Notes and Jubilee Notes, due to the collapse of Lehman Brothers. I did not like these structured products, but but I was not aware (until the collapse) that it could be so serious. I believe that there is something seriously wrong with the creation and marketing of these products, and that there is some possible wrong doing. I decided to organise a Petition to ask the Government to investigate if there were any wrong doing. This was done about one month ago. The Petition attracted 983 signatories.
2. Why did you decide to act for them, especially since you're not a victim yourself?
Reply: I consider it to be a public duty. If I find that there is something wrong and some many people are affected so badly, it is my responsibility as a citizen to help them to find redress. Actually, this is the resonsibility of the people in the Government. Perhaps they are too busy or not aware of the seriousness of the problem. I hope to raise their awareness, so that they can come forward to use their immense resources to do what needs to be done. After that, I can take a rest.
3. What incensed you the most about this whole saga?
Reply: Occasionally, I get angry. Most of the time, I am quite calm, in spite of the tremendous pressures that I faced in dealing with many distressed investors asking desperately for help.
I am angry that these structured products were allowed to be marketed to retail investors and that they were pushed by the financial institutions who has the responsibility to make the appropriate recommendation to the retail investors. I am angry that, even now, these parties are still not coming forward to do "the right thing". They are adding to the distress of the investors.
I appeal to them to act:
http://tankinlian.blogspot.com/2008/10/act-honourably.html
4. Do you personally know anyone who has bought these failed products?
Reply: I get to know many, many people who have bought these failed products, after the Petition was launched. They told some many heart rending stories to me. I passed their particulars (with their consent) to many journalists from the various mainstream papers, to interview them.
5. Many have hailed you as a hero in this saga. What are your thoughts on that?
Reply: I understand from history that many heroes died in the battle. I hope that I can survive and live to an older age.
6. What is the most heart rending story you've heard from any of the investors?
Reply: There are too many stories that fit into this category. I do not wish to degrade any of them, by singling out one story.
7. How do you think MAS has dealt with this crisis? Are you satisfied with what they've done?
Reply: I do not wish to pass any judgement on MAS. I have suggested in my Petition and in my blog, various actions that MAS could take to resolve this crisis. I hope that they will invite me for a dicussion on some of these suggestions. I also hope that they will adopt some of these suggestions to help resolve the crisis.
8. How do you think the petition and affidavits will help?
Reply: The Petition ask the Singapore Government to investigate if any of the laws had been breached. They are the Financial Advisers Act (section 27), Securities and Futures Act (section 199) and the Trustees Act and to take the appropriate action (if these laws have been breached).
The statutory declaration (previously referred to as the affidavit) allows the investors to give their honest statment under oath, regarding the assurances and explanations that they have received verbally from the sales representatives. They need to have a sworn statement as these statements may contradict the standard forms that they have signed (where the contents were not properly explained to them). We need the statutory declarations of hundreds or maybe thousands of investors to confirm that they were indeed given the wrong information to make their decisions.
9. What do you hope to see happen?
Reply: I hope that there can be a fair settlement. I hope that the financial institutions will offer to compensiate the investors for 50% to 80% of their loss.
Sunday, October 19, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
►
2009
(1580)
-
►
December
(33)
- Rechargeable torchlight with locator light
- Poor return on special funds
- Lock up for 2 years at low return
- Use of Medisave for health screening
- Temasek 20 and 30 year bonds
- Poor yield on life insurance policy
- Profit of health insurers
- John Bogel' website
- Lehman Note Arbitration in USA
- Tour of Jiuzhaigou, China
- Security measures went absurd
- Least corrupt countries
- Foreign shares listed in SGX
- Over-investing in mortgages
- Denying insurance claims
- Bus owner practices risk management
- Claim payable under a hospital bill
- Microsoft .NET developer
- Signs and messages
- Messy IT systems used in banks
- Insurance company need to hold more capital
- Creating jobs in America
- Low payout for medical claim
- The uninsured cannot afford health care
- Urgency to create jobs
- Avoid over insurance and moral hazard
- SCMP: Businessman sues Merill Lynch over loss on w...
- Policy loan
- How much life insurance to own?
- Optimism in Banda Aceh
- Holiday in Banda Aceh
- Risk Management
- Sayings of Confucius
-
►
November
(157)
- Emergency jobs program
- Location map - fast and easy
- Keynesian Economics
- False wealth
- Get Ready for Half a Recovery
- EPL matches for 2010
- Buy term insurance directly through internet porta...
- Termination of Living Policy
- Life insurance can serve a useful purpose
- Payout under CPF Life
- Family Income Benefit
- Keep cash, and be safe
- New immigrant's loyalty to Singapore
- An alternative to the free market economy
- Confucianism
- Pension planning
- Economic problems of Ireland
-
►
December
(33)
-
▼
2008
(2120)
-
▼
October
(352)
- Petition #4 - Review Complaint Handling Process
- High Notes Investor Group - Press release 30 Oct 0...
- Buy Government Bonds through ATM
- Undergraduate reply to Prof Lan
- News about Jubilee Notes arranger
- Conflict of interest between bank and customer
- Old news that may be useful
- NTUC Bonus Cut was a bad idea
- Financial Services Authority fines Lloyds Bank in ...
- Reply to Today Paper - "Structured Products ....."...
- Be empathic to investors who lost their savings
- LET'S NOT FORGET ABOUT PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY'
- Misleading Prospectus
- Thomas Jefferson's views on the banking system
- Talking point - minibonds and structured products
- Videos about speeches in Speaker's Corner
- US Attorney General recovers for investors in auct...
- High risk from inception
- Do you hear the people sing - version #4
- Mini-bond investor gives his view
- Savings of retired workers
- Collective legal action (1)
- Buying Government Securities
- Regulator should disallow the sale of bad products...
- Singapore Kopitiam Forum
- Nature and risk of the structured product
- Make Government Bonds easily available
- Not a happy time for me
- Misleading advertisements
- Why does the stock market fall?
- Unconditional help from volunteers
- NUS dean also exposed to loss
- Enforce the law
- Well regarded persons oversee the financial instit...
- Town Council invest in Minibond
- Jump on bandwagon
- Malaysia act against land banking
- Can investors understand CDO?
- Biggest loss in the the structured products
- CLSA Asks 500 Staff to Take Pay Cuts of Up to 25%
- Collapse of the global financial system
- Lehman Brother bond
- A fair compensation
- Prospectus needed
- A fair rate of return
- Electricity prices: 82% higher her than in Hong Ko...
- Profit margin in creating the structured product
- BBC radio documentary on structured products
- Call to MAS - pass general guideline for compensti...
- Husband's objection
- Blog for High Note investors
- Complaint Form
- It will be handled 'fairly'
- Interviews with Financial Institutions
- Unhappy with the interview
- Deposit Guarantee scheme in New Zealand
- Singapore Government guarantees bank deposits
- Leveraged Dual Currency Investments
- Pinnacle Notes - lodge a complaint now
- HK Monetary Authority refers 40 more 'mini-bonds' ...
- Speech at Speaker’s Corner – 25 Oct 2008
- SCMP: Angry investors protest
- Speaker's Corner - 25 October 2008
- A serious recession in the months ahead
- Call for Public Inquiry - some views
- No compensation from ABN AMRO
- Just One Year
- Investors want open forum with DBS
- Hong Kong: Legco raps shortcomings in minibonds mo...
- Global financial crisis is getting out of control
- Treat all investors fairly
- Response to: DBS begins process to compensate cust...
- Reputation as financial services hub
- High risk, absymal return
- Impact of Lehman Brothers on different types of se...
- Demand for Compensation
- A fair compensation
- Distributor should be responsible
- Hong Kong: Minibond investors demand full refund
- New swap counterparty
- Avoid land banking
- Requests for media interviews
- Draft: Letter to request for Open Forum
- Inteview with journalist (4)
- DBS Bank, Hong Leong Finance and Maybank to give c...
- Marketed to Asians
- A good settlement?
- Did the financial institution carry out any risk a...
- Understanding the technical terms
- Collective letter to distributor
- Collective legal action - request for proposals
- MAS push responsibility to Financial Institution
- Where does the BUCK STOP?
- Lawyer: No obligation, no fee consultation
- SCMP: Investors hit by Lehman collapse get papers ...
- Volunteers to write statements of complaints
- Post in my blog without Google account
- Block comments
- Response to Mr. Lim Hng Kiang and MAS
- Independent financial advisers are not able to com...
- Investors should not be compensated
- Do you hear the people sing
- Exploitation of the consumer
- Views from an ex-private banker
- MAS reply to Parliamentary Questions on Credit Lin...
- Interview at Bloomberg TV
- Continue your good work for ordinary citizens
- HKMA refers Lehman-Brothers-related cases to the S...
- Positive or negative?
- Petition #3 (To Mrs Lim Hwee Hua)
- Fraudalent misrepresentation and clear mis-selling...
- Be careful of your relationship manager
- Tips from an ex-financial adviser
- Be truthful, not fearful
- Petition #3 - Fair and equal compensation to all b...
- Onus of proof
- Volunteers to write statement of claim
- Jubilee Notes
- Speaker's Corner - Credit linked securities
- Suing for defamatory remarks
- Call to MAS - investigate mass cheating
- New list of investors sorted by distributor
- Conscience, integrity and trust - a leader's hallm...
- General advice to investors of structured products...
- Interview with Sunday Times
- Ask for a full refund now
- Do not succumb to greed
- Ask MAS for advice to sort out this type of proble...
- Not an isolated case
- Lehman Structured notes on Wheat and Milk
- Breach of the law - arguments
- Speech at Speaker's Corner - 11 Oct 2008
- Fall outside "vulnerable investors"
- Statutory declaration - Glenn Knight
- Lost the sense of bonding and togetherness
- Today: Man with a Mission
- TV news on MAS conference
- Investor meets HSBC Trustee
- Prompt reply to help "lost" investors
- Interview with Zaobao
- Interview with Today Paper
- MAS Media Release on Structured Products
- Meeting at Speaker's Corner 18 Oct, 6-7 pm
- Ray of light and hope
- Act with honour and integrity
- HKMA refers Lehman cases to regulator
- Dow Jones: Hong Kong banks will buy back mini-bond...
- Appeal to Financial Institutions - settle through ...
- A new financial system - back to the safe old days...
- Ponzi Scheme
- Caring and responsible country
- Petition to MAS - review sales training and market...
- HK: Tsang vows to get justice for minibonds invest...
- Petition to investigate the sales training
- Who let the sharks in?
- Fearful about speaking
- MAS International Advisory Panel (IAP)
- Impact of an offer to settle
- Hong Kong Chief Talks Tough on Minibonds - Bravo
- Request for MAS to give an update on the Petition
- Statement by DBS CEO
- Negotiate with financial institutions
- Hong Kong: Minibond fix may prove a risky business...
- New "petition" to collect particulars of investors...
- Jubilee Series 3 LinkEarner Notes
- Facilities at Speaker's Corner
- Strategy Committee for CLS
- Statutory declaration - 2 lawyers
- Statutory declaration - FiDREC
- Take collective legal action now?
- To the victims - be strong
- Caveat emptor: A licence to cheat
- Individual advice
- Specific product or distributor
- Effort to help the victims
- Meeting of High Notes investors
- The Online Citizen
- Ignorance and greed
- Protest outside DBS headquarters
- Leveraging and greed
- DBS will take responsibility, in some cases
- DBS to settle case by case: Rebecca Lee
- Look at the Product Advice
- Sales representatives did not know - misrepresenta...
- Hong Kong Lawmakers Criticize Bks Over Lehman-Back...
- FAQ from investors (1)
- Concern about disorderly behaviour
- Sales representatives should tell the truth and ad...
- HK legislators criticize regulators over bonds
- Credit linked securities were highly risky, even i...
- Low cost investment funds
- Elected President of Singapore
- Hit by Forex Losses
- Dual Currency Deposit (DCD)
- Weekly Speeches at Speaker's Corner
- Tan Kin Lian's speech at Speaker's Corner
- Minibond invetors are not risk takers
- Big loss on dual currency investment
- Forex or dual currency transactions
- SCMP: Banks risked reputations, watchdog says
- Nadya "Speaker" Zagarodnova
- Send this message to your Member of Parliament
- Weekly meetings at Hong Lim Green?
- Why the credit linked notes are highly risky
- Speaker's Corner - 11 October 2008
- Panic of AIA policyholders
- New blog for investors of Credit Linked Securities...
- STI Exchange Traded Fund
- Investing in difficult times
- Speech at Speaker's Corner: 11 Oct 2008
- Channel News Asia - report on Speaker's Corner
- Hong Kong: DBS first bank to repay bonds
- UOB Structured Notes
- Structured products are not sold in the UK
- Blogs for investors
- Volunteers to lead groups of investors
- Fight for the weak
- You have to take the risk and bear the loss
- Upset investors turn up at Speakers' Corner
- Greedy for profits
- Distributor: UOB Kay Hian
- Social responsibility to Singaporeans
- Speaker's Corner - 11 Oct 2008
- File an affidavit to support your claim
- Rebuilding the Global Financial System
- High cost of life insurance at older ages
- Class action against Lehman Brothers in USA
- Is MAS at fault?
- Unhappy with bank's complaint handling process (3)...
- Hong Kong - selling of structured products
- MAS publishes timeline for Minibond resolution pro...
- Climate of fear and intimidation
- Risky to trade on leverage
- Feedback on complaint handling process
- Difficulty with travel insurance claim
- Lehman Bond Probe Widens
- ST Index approaching 1900
- Petition has been lodged
- How the market really works
- Hong kong: Curb on banks' investment sales aired
- Complaint to MAS against a financial institition
- SCMP - DBS offers full compensationto mini-bond ho...
- Fiduciary duty
- HKMA vs MAS
- Global Financial Crisis - subprime loans
- Get information from my blog
- Book on financial planning
- Unhappy with bank's complaint handling process (2)...
- Bank agree to buy back risky investments
- No personal investment in credit linked securities...
- Media interviews on Petition
- Call for investors to take the next step
- Unhappy with bank's complaint handling process
- Financial institution fined for mis-selling
- Oversight of the complaint handling process
- Misleading advertisements
- Hong Kong: Minibond investors demand full refund
- Restrict the issue of credit cards
- Petition to Singapore Government - 983 signatures
- HKMA investigates complaints of alleged mis-sellin...
- South China Morning Post: 2003 case sets precedent...
- New type of foreign talent
- Poor payout on Anticipated Endowment policy
- Is bond fund risky?
- Legal fees - action against distributor
- Credit default swaps - who benefits?
- Coordinated interest rate cuts
- Reduced bonus under Income policies
- Dividend under STI ETF
- Credit default swap
- Full particulars of investors of credit linked sec...
- Hong kong - minibond buyback proposal
- File a police report
- Securities Investors Association of Singapore (SIA...
- Consumer Association
- Collective Action against specific distributors
- Unable to give individual advice or attend to indi...
- Monetary Authority of Singapore - Consumer Complai...
- ST Index is still falling
- Lodge your complaint with the Distributor
- Write to Monetary Authority of Singapore
- Meet the Member of Parliament
- My blog passes 500,000 visitors on 6 Oct 2008
- Petition to Singapore Government - Credit Linked S...
- Expensive to battle in court
- Consumer banking sells the structured products
- Loss of retirement savings
- Speaker's Corner, Saturday 11 October, 5 - 7 pm
- Section 199 of the Securities and Futures Act
- Section 27 of the Financial Advisers Act
- Request for help from Relationship Managers
- Petition on Credit Linked Securities, Singapore
- Capital protected product
- Service to the people
- CNBC short video on Minibond
- Is it wise to cash out on the structured product n...
- A highly risky structured product
- Selling of life insurance through multi-level
- Engaging a lawyer
- Elderly get hit the most!
- Greed and exploitation
- How to play Pro-Trader
- Pro-Trader Simulation Game
- In honour of J B Jeyaretnam
- Talk at NUS on 17 Oct 2008
- Minibond in Hong Kong
- Capital protection is not "capital guaranteed"
- Review internal complaints handling and resolution...
- Securities and Futures Act
- Petition to Singapore Government
- Not to be retailed in USA
- Petition to Singapore Government
- Banks deny refund deals for minibond investors
- Question for Member of Parliament
- Immense pressure to sell the structured products
- Meet your Members of Parliament
- Send feedback to NTUC Income
- Proposed Commission on Life Insurance Products
- Posting comments in my blog
- Failure to observe the risk assessment
- Ask your Member of Parliament
- Avoid going to court
- Merill Lynch Jubilee 3
- People to be blamed
- Loss of life savings
- Stop pushing financial products
- Hong Kong helping distressed people
- High commission and profits
- High risk investments
- Compensation to affected investors
- MAS announcements
- For defensive investors
- Hong Kong Government Meets Banks Accused Of Mis-se...
- Loss of hard earned money (2)
- In memory of Mr. J B Jeyaretnam
- Investigation into potential wrong-doings by finan...
- ANZ pays out $200,000 to elderly investor
- NTUC Income Money Market Fund (Flexi-cash)
- European Central Bank - an excellent approach
- Signing of Pettion
- Pressure on sales representatives to market certai...
- Fixed deposit with Singapore banks
- Saved by sound advice
- Pinnacle Series 11
- Tribute to Mr. J B Jeyaretnam
- Minibond Series 5
- Bank staff do not understand financial products
- HSBC Trustee
- High Notes 2
- Comments in my blog
- False Signatures at the Petition
- Mr. J B Jeyaretnam
-
▼
October
(352)
9 comments:
Mr Tan, you are our hero.
And you are right, nobody in spore would want to be a hero, if there is a choice.
I agree, cheers to you Mr Tan. finally all these issues is being given the limelight lately and today after so long our SM, Chairman spoke since his last comment about putting our savings into CPF instead.
Mr Tan, I hope your team could garnered for 100% refund and not lesser. The people has to stay united, unity is power, that's what the FIs fear most. The FIs will try to break this unision.
We need to set deadline for MAS and FIs. The longer they delay, people's confidence in the 'team' will just die down.
Besides getting lawyers to write, I hope we could gather signatures to ask for answers and not just the standard answer 'we are investigating', will look at case by case. If 1000 investors have similar issues, it is already a justifiable case.
Just becareful, our authorities will rope in FIDREC and other parties who may even have indirect 'interest' with FIs.
Mr Tan and team, keep it up. If your team need more helpers do make known through the blog, i am sure you will have more helpers.
Response to 7.20. We have to be realistic. Lehman has collapse, the low risk company has folded, unfortunate. All the investors who own notes that has the company should prepare to take some loss. It is the extend of the loss that we are talking about. If there are 5 entites (including Lehman), we should take at least 20% loss in the capital.
Should Mr. Tan one day decided to setup an opposition party, I believe he will really be the true force that could compete with PAP.
The future of Singapore will be much brighter..
Hi 2:05 PM
If I get involved, I will set up a "political party" and not an "opposition party". Do not assume that PAP will always be the "ruling party".
I never expected you to say this so explicitly. Since you did, I offer you my support and my best wishes. Ethical politicians are hard to find these days.
"we are investigating, will look at case by case"
This is a blatant "divide and rule" tactic. Petitioners should remain united or your cause will fail.
Mr Tan, thank you for standing up for all investors. In the past "hero" usually die first, especially if directly against some establishments......but in this case, it is different. You are just speaking the truth and helping victims. And there isn't any religion, race or sensitive issues that you are poking into.....
I am a victim of sorts and have both high notes 2 and minibonds. i am extremely disappointed with the way DBS has handle the whole issue especially HN2. While I am aware of the risk link to the reference entity, I am not aware of the risk that came with Constellation (all they told us is the risk with the reference entity). For 2 good years after I bought HN2, DBS did not even tell us the securities that were held and that investors were subjected to the risk of 100 companies. Suddenly they decided to come clean and publish the list. And they keep telling you that all risk are in the subscription form and prospectus. To be honest, how many people can really understand the legalistic jaron, reference, cross references in all those documents? This has nothing to do with whether you are English-Educated or not.......And don't bother calling them.....their scripts are crafted to tell you that you are at fault for not reading all the forms....
If one take a look at the list of 100 company, one could see that they are all Senior notes. How could one single default by Lehman Brothers wipe out almost all of the value of the protfolio? By the way, Freddie and Fannie Notes are also senior and the US government had said that "bond" holders will be protected. For Freddie and Fannie, the market has already auction off a value for the Credit Default Swap. Thus I still do not understand how could the portfolio be at 11.5%
Enough of complaining. My feel is that the worst scenario now is to "mark-to-market" and liquidate the portfolio. The next best thing is really to hold out and wait for it to mature. DBS should come clean and be transparent about what is actually held in the portfolio and the risk investors are subjected to.
The same for minibond. If liquidated, the value should be very low, so the best solution is really to have a counter swap party and continue the issue.
My heart goes out to those who have HN5....
The newspaper seems to picture minibond and hn holders to be greedy etc etc. I believe that all are very conservative people who were asked to invest in what is "as safe as fixed deposit". A Marketing gimmick. Now who is greddy??
Response to 11.24AM
For cases that proved that there is indeed mis-selling and mispresenation by the FIs, nvestors should get back 100% because this is cheating by the FIs, this is against the law. Why should the victims take part of the loss ?? Indeeed, the FIs should even be made to pay compensation !
Post a Comment