Poor Return from New Plan

A customer sent the benefit illustration for a newly introduced plan called Reach. I analysed it as follows:

This is a 10 year Reach policy with an annual premium of $5,000 payable for 5 years. Subsequently, the policy pays a cash coupon for the next 5 years. The coupons can be accumulated with interest. Based on the non-guaranteed interest rate of 3% per annum payable on the cash coupons, the total amount at maturity represented a yield of about 1.2% p.a. For a 10 year investment, this is a poor yield and is not even guaranteed.

The same company had a single premium plan, called Growth, which gave a non-guaranteed yield of 2.7% or 3.5% over 7 years, which was more acceptable. It seemed that the old plan gave a better return, compared to the new plan.

It is better for the consumer to invest in the STI ETF, which is flexible and gives a better long term yield.  Read my financial planning book for more information.