Survey: Do you agree with this idea? Give your views here.
Singaporeans, especially, the elderly, are worried about the cost of health-care. The government is also worried and tries to push the cost to the public. In most cases, the actual cost may be affordable, but the perception is that the cost is getting out of hand.
To address this issue, we have created a convoluted system of different tiers of charges for different groups of people and a convoluted system of payment through the Medisave, Medishield and Medifund (labelled as the 3Ms). The Government is proud of the 3Ms but there is little enthusiasm for this approach outside Singapore (and, in case I am wrong, I stand corrected).
The system used in the British National Health System is better. The citizens receive free medical consultation with their personal doctor (and referrals to specialists made by these personal doctors) but have to pay for medication, which are prescribed by independent pharmacists. This is a practical system that does not require payment to the doctors. The doctors are paid by the state.
The concept works well and is a practical approach. Patients will see the doctors only it is necessary. Even if they see the doctor more often than necessary, the doctor will be able to handle it. There is little chance of abuse. Medication is charged at the commercial rate (but there may be some system of subsidy). It will prevent the patient from getting medication to sell to other people, e.g. foreigners who are not on the system.
How can we implement some of the concept of the British NHS in Singapore? I suggest that every resident should open an account with MOH. All treatment from the public sector hospitals (and some authorized private sector) should be charged to this account. At the end of each month, the payments are made to the providers and are collected from the respective payment sources (e.g. cash, Medisave or insurance). There is no need to levy charges at the point of use. This will reduce the perception of the high cost of health care.
Most people will be able to pay for the medical charges on the monthly bills, which can be deducted from Medisave. There is the risk of bad debts from people who refuses to pay the cash component. This is a risk that can be managed. The government face a bigger risk of the non-payment of taxes and have ways to prosecute people who do not pay. This can be applied to medical care.
For the elderly and the poor, the government can take care of a portion of the medical bills. This can be easily managed on the monthly statements. They can also deal with the cases of high consumption. In the worst case of abuse, the patients can be cutoff from access to the service.
I believe that the approach that I have described is practiced in Canada. I like this approach as it will reduce the workload of our medical facilities (who do not have to collect fees at the point of consultation) and also reduce the perception of high cost of medical care. Any extreme cases can be dealt separately, outside of the delivery of the service.
Tan Kin Lian
- ► 2019 (1280)
- ► 2018 (1406)
- ► 2017 (1258)
- ► 2016 (828)
- ► 2015 (691)
- ► 2014 (144)
- ► 2013 (501)
- ► 2012 (1269)
02/20 - 02/27
- Family Life Challenge
- Excessive behavior and profit
- Risk Management for Young People
- Expensive medical bill
- Stay with Medishield
- How to develop a good customer support system
- Customer Support - how to develop a good system
- Excellent customer support - Dropbox
- Arab unrest: 5 eyewitnesses to history (from CNN)
- Election secrecy
- Life in Singapore - Utopia or Dystopia
- Logic Box
- Chee Soon Juan speaks on the Reform Party issue
- This election, your life, your promise
- Financial Planning Talk by Tan Kin Lian
- SDP Anniversary Dinner, 2011
- New FISCA website
- Consumer financial issues
- Policy of give and take
- Higher rentals for food stalls
- Poor feeder service
- Donation to FISCA
- HK Government issues inflation linked bonds
- What values characterize Singapore?
- Perspective of a financial adviser in Europe
- A simple will
- Bus lanes pose accident hazard
- Finding a lawyer
- Talk on Financial Planning
- Family Life Challenge
- Excellent signage
- Traffic Congestion
- Locate your car
- Travel by bus or MRT
- Highway construction and corruption
- $8 heart bypass surgery
- Sorry tale of local professors in Singapore
- More money than your neighbours
- How to get a higher yield
- Revolution in the Middle East
- Financial Plan - revised format
- Wine Investment - complaint about cheating
- Family Life Challenge (win book prizes worth $20)
- Traditional Chinese Medicine - reply to Dr. Colin ...
- Use Google Map to get directions
- Budget 2011 - 73% are disappointed
- Soft launch of "Get Value from your Life Insurance...
- The future of Singapore - a view from a young Sing...
- Talk on Sudoku and Puzzles
- Singapore - before and after 1985
- Unemployment insurance in Germany
- Canada has a better health care system
- Doctors on house calls
- New approach to health care
- Treat people equally
- From Dictatorship to Democracy
- TOTO and GINI coefficient
- Budget 2011 - some views of the people
- ▼ 02/20 - 02/27 (58)
- ► 2010 (2369)
- ► 2009 (1654)
- ► 2008 (2104)
- ► 2007 (1803)
- ► 2006 (696)
- ► 2005 (159)