Monday, February 21, 2011

Traditional Chinese Medicine - reply to Dr. Colin Ng

Printed in St Times Online Forum


I refer to the letter from Dr. Colin Lim, entitled “SMA’s confusing suggestion (ST 17 Feb 2011).

I agree with the approach taken by the council of the Singapore Medical Association to allow the use of alternative medicine.

My family have enjoyed the use of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) for three generations. It has been effective in overcoming some health problems that can be corrected by restoring the balance in the body. We seek western medicine only for the more serious conditions. This has helped us to reduce the cost of medical care.

Singapore does not have sufficient doctors who are trained in western medicine to take care of our large population, including the growing number of elderly people. We need all the available resources. The TCM practitioners can play a role in the areas that they are good in.

I agree with Dr. Ng on the value of getting evidence on the effectiveness of the TCM practices. While there is a lack of data of the effective of TCM, based on the approach of data collation used in western medicine, we must not overlook the fact that TCM has been used by many generations and have been found to be useful. If TCM was not useful, it would have been abandoned long ago.

Tan Kin Lian
Posted by at

2 comments:

yujuan said...

Not all western doctors are biased against TCM. My orthopaedic doctor at SGH advised me to seek complementary TCM treatment for my
backbone stenosis through a cute and sneaky way, by quietly asking his nursing assistant to shove me a TCM doctor's name card.
I was taken completely by surprise.

February 21, 2011 10:53 PM
Anonymous said...

"While there is a lack of data of the effective of TCM, based on the approach of data collation used in western medicine, we must not overlook the fact that TCM has been used by many generations and have been found to be useful. If TCM was not useful, it would have been abandoned long ago."

Just because something has been around for a long time doesn't mean that it actually works. I bet that if you compare the mortality rates and life expectancy of people in ancient china and modern china, you'll notice a whole lot of difference.

What's the difference? Modern medicine that relies on the scientific method.

February 22, 2011 12:10 PM

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Blog Archive